On The Shoulders Of Giants: Private Sector Leverages Hgp Successes

echnologies Catalyze a New, High-Profile Liferepay fundamental public investments. Following
Sciences Industryare a few key public R&D contributions that
The deluge of data and related technologiesmade some current genomics ventures
generated by the Human Genome Project (HGP)commercially feasible. These examples describe
and other genomic research presents a broadDOE investments, but substantial commitments
array of commercial opportunities. Seeminglyby NIH and the Wellcome Trust in the United
limitless applications cross boundaries fromKingdom were equally important.
medicine and food to energy and environmentalScientific Infrastructure. The scientific foundation
resources, and predictions are that life sciencesfor a human genome initiative existed at the
may become the largest sector in the U.S.national laboratories before DOE established the
economy.first genome project in 1986. Besides expertise in
Established companies are scrambling to retool,a number of areas critical to genomic research,
and many new ventures are seeking a role in thethe laboratories had a long history of conducting
information revolution with DNA at its core. IBM,large multidisciplinary projects.
Compaq, DuPont, and major pharmaceuticalGenomic Science and Pioneering Technology.
companies are among those interested in theGenBank, the world's DNA sequence repository,
potential for targeting and applying genome data.was developed at Los Alamos National Laboratory
In the genomics corner alone, dozens of small(LANL) and later transferred to the National
companies have sprung up to sell information,Library of Medicine. Chromosome-sorting
technologies, and services to facilitate basiccapabilities developed at LANL and Lawrence
research into genes and their functions. TheseLivermore National Laboratory enabled the
new entrepreneurs also offer an abundance ofdevelopment of DNA clone libraries representing
genomic services and applications, includingthe individual chromosomes. These libraries were a
additional databases with DNA sequences fromcrucial resource in genome sequencing.
humans, animals, plants, and microbes.Sequencing Strategies. When the HGP was
Other applications include gene fragments to useinitiated, vital automation tools and high-throughput
for drug development and target identification andsequencing technologies had to be developed or
evaluation, identification of candidate genes, andimproved. The cost of sequencing a single DNA
RNA expression information revealing genebase was about $10 then; today, sequencing
activity. Products include protein profiles; particularcosts have fallen about 100-fold to $.10 to $.20 a
genotypes associated with such specific medicallybase and still are dropping rapidly.
important phenotypes as disease susceptibility andDOE-funded enhancements to sequencing
drug responsiveness; hardware, software, andprotocols, chemical reagents, and enzymes
reagents for DNA sequencing and othercontributed substantially to increasing efficiencies.
DNA-based tests; microarrays (DNA chips)The commercial marketing of these reagents has
containing tens of thousands of known DNA andgreatly benefitted basic R&D, genome-scale
RNA fragments for research or clinical use; andsequencing, and lower-cost commercial diagnostic
DNA analysis software.services.
Broader applications reaching into many areas ofSequencing Technologies and Biological Resources.
the economy include the following:Other major factors in cost and time reduction
* Clinical medicine. Many more individualizedare greatly improved sequencing instruments and
diagnostics and prognostics, drugs, and otherefficient biological resources such as the following:
therapies.* DOE-funded research on capillary- based DNA
* Agriculture and livestock. Hardier, moresequencing contributed to the development of the
nutritious, and healthier crops and animals.two major sequencing -machines now in use. The
* Industrial processes. Cleaner and more efficientcore optical system concept of the Perkin-Elmer
manufacturing in such sectors as chemicals, pulp3700 sequencing machine (used by Celera and
and paper, textiles, food, fuels, metals, andothers) was pioneered with DOE support. The
minerals.instrumentation concepts that matured as the
* Environmental biotechnology. BiodegradableMegaBACE sequencer were pioneered by Richard
products, new energy resources, environmentalMathies (University of California, Berkeley). The
diagnostics, and less hazardous cleanup of mixedDOE JGI chose this sequencing hardware platform
toxic-waste sites.after competitive trials.
* DNA fingerprinting. Identification of humans and* DNA sequencing originally was done with
other animals, plants, and microbes; evolutionaryradiolabeled DNA fragments. Today, DOE
and human anthropological studies; and detectionimprovements to fluorescent dyes -decrease the
of and resistance to harmful agents that might beamount of DNA needed and increase the
used in biological warfare.accuracy of sequencing data.
From the start, HGP planners anticipated and* Bacterial artificial chromosome (BAC) clones,
promoted the private sector's participation indeveloped in the DOE program, became the
developing and commercializing genomic resourcespreferred starting resource in sequencing
and applications. The HGP's successes inprocedures because of their superior stability and
establishing an infrastructure and fundinglarge size. A critical component of public- and
high-throughput technology development areprivate-sector sequencing, BACs were used to
giving rise to commercially viable products andassemble both the draft and final human DNA
services, with the private sector now taking onreference -sequences.
more of the risk.* Further extending the usefulness of BACs, the
A Public LegacyDOE HGP funded the production of sequence tag
Substantial public-sector R&D investment often isconnectors (STCs) from BAC ends. This early
needed in feasibility demonstrations before suchinformation enabled the selection of optimal BACs
start-up ventures as those by Celera Genomics,for complete sequencing, thus saving time and
Incyte, and Human Genome Sciences can begin. Inmoney. STC use for the HGP was advocated by
turn, these companies furnish valuable commercialCraig Venter and Nobelist Hamilton Smith (both at
services that the government cannot provide, andCelera), and Leroy Hood (now at the Institute for
the taxes returned by their successes easilySystems Biology).